Peterborough County paramedics set to strike Monday morning as contract talks reach impasse
CUPE 4911 president says public safety, staffing shortages, burnout and pay equity are at the centre of the dispute; reduced ambulance coverage could also affect Northumberland County
Peterborough County paramedics are preparing to walk off the job Monday morning, November 16, at 6 a.m., marking the first strike action in the 25-year history of the county’s paramedic service.
Despite repeated efforts by the union to return to the bargaining table, CUPE Local 4911 President Jordan Lean told Today’s Northumberland on Sunday, November 15, that negotiations remain at an impasse, with no agreement in sight.
“We’ve extended multiple offers to get back to the bargaining table with them. They’ve either been responded to with a no or not answered at all.”
With approximately 15 to 16 hours remaining before the scheduled strike deadline at the time of the interview, Lean said the likelihood of job action was becoming increasingly certain.
At the centre of the dispute are four major issues: recruitment, retention, mental health support and pay equity.
Lean said paramedics in Peterborough County and the City of Peterborough are seeking compensation that better reflects the demands of their profession and brings their wages closer to those of other emergency first responders.
He specifically pointed to police and firefighters in Peterborough, saying their compensation packages are approximately 20 per cent higher than those of paramedics.
The union also wants improved mental health coverage for both full-time and part-time paramedics.
Lean acknowledged the County has offered $5,000 annually for full-time paramedics and $2,000 for part-time employees but said the proposal does not adequately address the concerns of members.
“There are some caveats with it that we’re not comfortable with agreeing to for our membership,” he said.
He added that the proposed coverage does not fully address the mental health challenges, burnout and post-traumatic stress disorder facing paramedics.
Experienced paramedics leaving
Recruitment and retention have become increasingly difficult, according to Lean.
“We’re losing senior medics, experienced medics, people that have been in the community for a number of years and they’re leaving to go to other services, police and fire because of better benefit packages and compensation,” he said.
The union is also concerned about attracting newly graduated paramedics when other employers across Ontario are competing for the same qualified applicants.
Lean said improved compensation and working conditions are necessary to keep experienced paramedics in the community while attracting new employees.
Public could experience ambulance delays
Although many people may assume paramedics are classified as an essential service, Lean explained that paramedic services are not legally considered an essential service in the same way as some other emergency operations.
However, labour legislation and the Essential Ambulance Services Agreement require a minimum level of emergency coverage to continue during a strike.
That means emergency 9-1-1 calls will continue to be answered, but residents could notice a significant reduction in available ambulances.
Lean said the service normally operates with 32 paramedics on frontline trucks.
During the strike, that number will drop to 20 during the day and 14 overnight.
The reduction will mean two fewer ambulances operating each day, along with the temporary suspension of the Community Paramedicine program.
The union estimates overall frontline ambulance staffing will be reduced by 20 per cent.
Lean said the Community Paramedicine program currently serves approximately 1,000 to 1,100 patients throughout Peterborough County.
Those patients will temporarily be without community paramedic care during the labour disruption.
“If you’re in the Community Paramedic program and experience an emergency, call 9-1-1,” the union stated in its public notice.
Lean warned the reduced number of ambulances could create delays, particularly because the service is already struggling to meet call volumes with its regular staffing complement.
“As it stands now, we’re having a hard time just meeting the call volume with 100% complement,” he said.
“So even a 20% reduction, I’m anticipating that there will be calls waiting, delays for service.”
Increasing demands on paramedics
Lean said the growing number of calls involving mental health, addiction and drug overdoses has placed additional pressure on an already strained emergency response system.
He pointed to the increase in calls over the past three to five years, particularly involving mental health and addiction issues.
Many of those calls do not result in a patient being transported to hospital, but they still occupy ambulances and paramedics who could otherwise be responding to other emergencies.
He said the increasing workload is contributing to burnout among frontline staff.
“Currently, one of our issues that we’re fighting for is just reducing the amount of workload that our medics are doing every day,” Lean said.
“It’s getting to the point where it’s unbearable. You start a shift, you go for 12 hours, 13 hours sometimes, and the calls don’t stop.”
He said paramedics working during the strike are understandably apprehensive about what the reduced staffing levels will mean when call volumes remain high.
Northumberland County could feel the impact
The strike could have consequences beyond Peterborough County, particularly for neighbouring Northumberland County and the City of Kawartha Lakes.
The three services operate under a shared-services agreement that allows them to assist one another when staffing shortages or call volumes create difficulties.
Lean said the reduced number of Peterborough ambulances could mean neighbouring services will be called upon more frequently.
He specifically identified southern Peterborough County as an area where Northumberland paramedics could be required to respond to calls.
That could leave fewer ambulances available in Northumberland communities.
“If our truck is normally in Port Hope and it’s up in Bailieboro doing a call for Peterborough County, there will be a delay down in Port Hope receiving care,” Lean explained.
The potential impact on neighbouring communities is another concern as the dispute moves into strike action.
In its statement, Peterborough County acknowledged it may need to request assistance from neighbouring paramedic services and said it recognizes the potential impact on those services and their communities.
First strike in 25 years
Lean confirmed this will be the first strike vote and first strike action in the history of Peterborough County’s paramedic service, which has operated under the County banner for 25 years.
For union members, the prospect of walking a picket line is not something they wanted.
“We don’t want to be on the picket lines. We’d rather just be doing our regular job and being on the frontline serving our community,” Lean said.
He described the situation as bittersweet, expressing hope that strike action will finally bring the changes needed to make the service sustainable.
“Our biggest concern is public safety,” he said.
“We don’t ever want to see a situation that a delay in service impacts somebody in the community.”
Lean said the union wants the County to return to the bargaining table sooner rather than later.
County says its offer is fair and competitive
In a statement provided by Peterborough County, the municipality said it was disappointed the dispute had reached the point of a potential strike.
The County maintains it has presented a fair and competitive offer and remains committed to reaching an agreement.
According to the County, its proposal includes wage increases totalling almost 18 per cent over three years.
The County said that, based on collective agreements settled to date, the proposed increase represents the highest wage increase in Eastern Ontario and ranks among the top 10 in Ontario.
The offer also includes annual mental health benefits of $5,000 for full-time paramedics and $2,000 for part-time paramedics.
The County also disputed the union’s position on compensation, stating that CUPE 4911’s most recent wage proposal would make Peterborough County paramedics the highest paid in Ontario by 2028, based on current wage settlements.
The County said it proposed independent interest arbitration as an alternative to strike action, but the union declined.
Interest arbitration would involve an independent third party considering comparable collective agreements and settlements before making a binding decision on the outstanding issues.
The County said most paramedic labour disputes in Ontario over the past 25 years have been resolved through this process.
Disagreement over ambulance staffing
The two sides also provided different perspectives on how the reduced staffing levels were established.
The County said it initially sought to maintain staffing levels during a strike, proposing only a 10 per cent reduction.
According to the County, the union proposed a significantly larger reduction.
The final Essential Ambulance Services Agreement, signed November 6, provides for a 20 per cent reduction in staffing, which the County described as a negotiated compromise.
The agreement also provides for the suspension of Community Paramedicine and the tactical team during a strike.
The County emphasized that emergency ambulance services will continue, with 68 paramedics staffing 10 ambulances during the day and seven overnight.
Residents are being reminded to call 9-1-1 whenever they experience a medical emergency.
The County also stated it will not lock out its paramedics and that its offer, along with its proposal for arbitration or further negotiations, remains on the table.
Both sides say they want a resolution
The union maintains it is prepared to negotiate around the clock to avoid a disruption, while the County says it remains willing to pursue further negotiations or arbitration.
However, as of Sunday evening, no new bargaining dates had been scheduled.
For residents of Peterborough County and neighbouring communities, the immediate concern is what happens when fewer ambulances are available to respond to emergencies.
For Lean, the dispute is about more than a wage settlement.
He said the union believes the long-term sustainability of the service is at stake, and that failing to address staffing, recruitment, retention and mental health concerns will only make the situation worse.
“We need sustainable paramedic service that they can count on for years to come,” Lean said.
“The cracks are starting to show now and that’s why we’re pushing as hard as we are right now.”
The scheduled strike deadline is Monday, November 16, at 6 a.m.